CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (2024)

MORE LIKE THISCertificates of DepositSavings AccountsBanking

Which is the better place to park your money: a certificate of deposit or savings account? Savings accounts give you more flexibility to make withdrawals, but CDs offer fixed interest rates that can boost some savings if you’re able to leave your money alone for a set time. The best place to deposit your cash generally depends on how long you’re willing to leave it in your account.

» Skip down to a comparison table of these two account types

Savings accounts

What is a savings account? A savings account is a bank account that typically earns interest. You can withdraw money as needed, though some banks limit the number of times you can make certain types of withdrawals. If you exceed the limit, the bank may charge a fee — say, $3 or $5 — for each extra transaction. If there are repeated excess withdrawals, the bank may close the account or convert it to a checking account.

The withdrawal limit used to be a federal requirement, but the Federal Reserve removed the requirement in response to the pandemic. As a result, some financial institutions do not enforce transfer limits. Before opening an account, be sure to check with the institution about its policy.

When is a savings account a good choice? A savings account is a good choice if you need to access your money in the near future. Savings accounts are especially good for emergency funds because they can offer fast access to cash if you incur an unexpected expense. CDs, on the other hand, often charge a penalty to make early withdrawals.

To get the most out of savings, place your money in a high-yield savings account. These accounts are often offered by online banks and credit unions. (Read more about NerdWallet's favorite high-yield savings accounts.)

The national average rate on savings accounts is only 0.45%, but a high-interest savings account can earn close to 10 times the national average. It may not make you rich, but the extra money can help.

High-yield savings accounts vs. CDs: High-yield savings accounts, as well as basic savings accounts, generally have rates that are variable and can change at any time, while a CD locks in a rate for the term period, such as one or five years. Use NerdWallet’s savings calculator to explore how much your money could earn with different rates.

» COMPARE: Average rates for four types of bank accounts

🤓Nerdy Tip

Today’s high rates may not last forever. Take advantage of them while you can with a federally insured high-yield savings account or certificate of deposit.

Marcus by Goldman Sachs High-Yield CD

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (2)

APY

5.10%

Term

6 months

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (3)

Learn More

Member FDIC

EverBank CD

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (4)

APY

5.05%

Term

9 months

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (5)

Learn More

Member FDIC

Marcus by Goldman Sachs High-Yield CD

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (6)

APY

5.00%

Term

1 year

EXPLORE MORE ACCOUNTS

Certificates of deposit

What is a CD? A CD is a type of savings account that can pay a higher interest rate than a high-yield savings account in exchange for removing access to your funds during the CD term. Standard terms range from three months to five years, but can be as short as one month and as long as 10 years. If you take your money out before the term ends, you generally pay a penalty that’s a portion of the interest you earned.

When is a CD a good choice? CDs can be a good choice if you’re certain you won’t need your cash for several months or years and want a consistent rate of return. Typically, a CD is a supplemental account that doesn’t replace the need to have a regular savings account for everyday savings. If you want to know more about choosing a term and type of CD, read our CD explainer.

Many CDs have rates that are higher than the best savings account yields. Find top options by searching the best CD rates and compare them with the best savings rates.

Timing the opening of a CD to get a good rate: CDs allow you to lock in a rate for the length of the term, which is great if rates are expected to fall soon. But rates have been on the rise. If you already locked in a CD, you might end up earning less than if you had chosen to put your funds in a high-yield savings account. (You can decide to break a CD early for a better rate if the math works in your favor.)

» Learn more about the rate environment on our CD rate forecast

There is a straightforward way to lower the risk of being stuck with unfavorable CD rates: creating a CD ladder. It involves opening several CDs with varying term lengths instead of putting all your money in a single account. As each shorter-term CD matures, you’d move the balance into a new long-term CD. This allows you to take advantage of the traditionally higher rates that long-term CDs offer while regularly having access to maturing CDs. To learn more about this approach, read our explainer on CD ladders.

You can also manage risk by opening a bump-up CD, which lets you request a rate increase during the term, or a step-up CD, which offers automatic rate increases.

CD vs. high-yield savings account: At a glance

CD

High-yield savings account

Pros

  • Higher rates on top CDs than savings accounts typically.

  • Fixed rate locks in predictable rate of return.

  • Locking in your money builds in distance from these savings.

  • Competitive rates.

  • Withdrawals at any time (though some banks still enforce limits).

  • Ability to add money over time.

  • No penalty for withdrawals.

Cons

  • Penalty if you withdraw before the term ends, typically.

  • No ability to add more money after the initial deposit usually.

  • Locking in a rate can mean missing out on higher rates potentially.

  • Rates can change at any time.

  • No built-in barrier to prevent spending temptations.

How to open a savings account or CD

You can typically open a savings account or CD the way you would any other bank account: Visit a branch or sign up on the bank's website. You'll likely need to provide ID and some additional information, such as your address and Social Security number. You can open CDs from credit unions (the credit union versions of CDs are called share certificates), online banks and traditional banking institutions. (Read more about how to open a savings account or CD.)

» Problems opening a bank account? Read our guide on the steps you can take

The minimum opening balance for a CD is often more than the minimum required to open a savings account, but some financial institutions let you open CDs with no minimum.

Once you open the best account for your situation, you’ll be able to take the most enjoyable step: Sit back and watch your money grow.

Save smarter with Max

Optimize your savings with our new partner Max, and manage your funds for the best return.

JOIN NOW

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (7)

Compare types of bank accounts

  • Savings vs. Checking.

  • Savings vs. MMAs.

  • Savings vs. CDs.

  • Savings vs. No-penalty CDs.

  • Savings vs. CMAs.

  • MMAs vs. CDs.

  • How to choose a bank.

  • How to choose a bank account.

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet (2024)

FAQs

CD vs. High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? - NerdWallet? ›

High-Yield Savings Account: Which Should I Choose? Savings accounts give you more flexibility to make withdrawals, but CDs can offer higher interest rates. Margarette Burnette is a NerdWallet authority on savings, who has been writing about bank accounts since before the Great Recession.

Is a CD better than a high interest savings account? ›

If your goal is to lock in a high rate of interest on funds you don't need to access for a period of time, a CD might be your best option. However, a high-yield savings account may be the better choice if you want to earn solid interest on your savings while still keeping the money relatively accessible.

Why shouldn't I use a high-yield savings account? ›

While high-yield savings accounts offer high APYs and zero risk, they're not the best way to grow your wealth long-term. That's because your APY can go up and down, and your yield may not outpace the inflation rate.

Why would a customer want a CD rather than a savings account? ›

CD accounts may offer better interest rates than savings accounts. Longer terms will usually also have more favorable rates.

What is the drawback of a CD compared to a savings account? ›

Limited liquidity

One major drawback of a CD is that account holders can't easily access their money if an unanticipated need arises. They typically have to pay a penalty for early withdrawals, which can eat up interest and can even result in the loss of principal.

Why is CD not a good financial investment? ›

Banks and credit unions can penalize savers who withdraw CD funds before maturity. CD rates may not be high enough to keep pace with inflation when consumer prices rise. Investing money in the stock market could generate much higher returns than CDs.

What is the biggest negative of putting your money in a CD? ›

Banks and credit unions often charge an early withdrawal penalty for taking funds from a CD ahead of its maturity date. This penalty can be a flat fee or a percentage of the interest earned. In some cases, it could even be all the interest earned, negating your efforts to use a CD for savings.

Should I move all my money to a high-yield savings account? ›

While you can grow your money with an HYSA, it's not the best way to generate long-term wealth for retirement because the yield often doesn't keep up with inflation. As a result, working with a broker or robo-advisor to develop an investment portfolio is better for long-range plans.

Can I lose my money in a high-yield savings account? ›

Losing money in an HYSA is rare, but it can happen.

This type of deposit account is available through many banks and credit unions, particularly online financial institutions. An HYSA works like a traditional savings account, except it offers a much higher annual percentage yield (APY).

What is the catch to a high-yield savings account? ›

What are the cons of a high-yield savings account? Variable rates. Interest rates on these accounts can and do fluctuate, which means the APY you started with could potentially drop. Keep your eye on such changes and remember that the money is yours; at any time, you can move it to a bank that offers a higher rate.

Are CDs safe if the market crashes? ›

Are CDs safe if the market crashes? Putting your money in a CD doesn't involve putting your money in the stock market. Instead, it's in a financial institution, like a bank or credit union. So, in the event of a market crash, your CD account will not be impacted or lose value.

Should you put all your savings in a CD? ›

Bottom Line. CDs can be a safe way to earn a little interest on your savings over a set period of time. But don't put more money in CDs than you can afford to lose access to for the length of the CD's term. Once your money is in a CD, you generally can't touch it without penalty until it matures.

How much does a $10,000 CD make in a year? ›

Earnings on a $10,000 CD Over Different Terms
Term LengthAverage APYInterest earned on $10,000 at maturity
1 year2.59%$262.10
18 months2.22%$338.29
2 years2.08%$424.40
3 years1.94%$598.77
3 more rows
3 days ago

What is one benefit of a CD over a high-yield savings account? ›

Also, the interest rate offered by high-yield savings accounts can change while your money is in the account but with CDs, the rate you lock in when you make a deposit stays the same throughout the entire term. This can be a good thing if you open an account before the rate drops.

Can CD accounts lose money? ›

Some CDs are penalty-free. You can get a better rate on short-term CDs than long-term CDs right now. It's actually possible to lose money on CDs.

Should I lock in a CD now or wait? ›

Unlike traditional or high-yield savings accounts, which have variable APYs, most CDs lock your money into a fixed interest rate the day you open the account. That's why if you suspect that interest rates will soon drop, it can be a good idea to put money in a CD to preserve the high APY you would earn.

Is a CD better than a high-yield savings account 2024? ›

A high-yield savings account generally pays a higher interest rate than the national average for savings accounts. However, a CD often pays a higher interest rate than a high-yield savings account. As of April 2024, several banks and credit unions were offering high-yield savings accounts with APYs above 5%.

What happens if you put $500 in a CD for 5 years? ›

For example, if you deposit $500 in a five-year CD that earns a 5.15% APY, your balance by the end of five years will be $642.71, earning you $142.71 in interest. However, if the interest rate is 3.25%, your earnings will only be $586.71, a difference of $56 in interest earnings.

Why should you deposit $5000 in CD now? ›

Higher interest rates

Rates on CDs are the highest they've been in years, with many online banks offering savers an APY of 5.5% or greater. Compared to the 0.43% many are getting with a regular savings account, you're essentially losing money by not withdrawing your money and depositing it into a CD instead.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Margart Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 6042

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Margart Wisoky

Birthday: 1993-05-13

Address: 2113 Abernathy Knoll, New Tamerafurt, CT 66893-2169

Phone: +25815234346805

Job: Central Developer

Hobby: Machining, Pottery, Rafting, Cosplaying, Jogging, Taekwondo, Scouting

Introduction: My name is Margart Wisoky, I am a gorgeous, shiny, successful, beautiful, adventurous, excited, pleasant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.